June 14 – November 25, 2017
Take part in the adventure and embrace the endless possibilities of imagination in this action-packed coming-of-age prequel to Peter Pan. The five-time Tony-winning Broadway hit, ideally suited to the signature ASC style, brings to life the heart-warming and richly imaginative story of how Neverland and Peter Pan came to life. Filled with music, mermaids, a celestial treasure, a spunky leading lady, a band of wacky pirates, an island crawling with intrigue, and one absurdly wicked Captain, Peter and the Starcatcher will make you fly.
Cast

Benjamin Reed *
Peter
Benjamin has been a resident company member with the American Shakespeare Center since 2014.

Allie Babich *
Prentiss
Allie Babich is an innovative performer and director whose bold vision and creative energy inspire captivating storytelling at ASC and beyond.

Josh Innerst
Ted
Hamlet in Hamlet; Mowbray, Percy, Groom in Richard II; Hamlet in Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead; Petulant in The Way of the World; Castillo, Senator in Antonio’s Revenge.

Lauren Ballard
Molly Aster
Lauren has been an actor at the American Shakespeare Center in 32 productions and is currently the Properties Master and Choreographer for the Summer/Fall Season. She has a BA from …

René Thornton Jr. *
Lord Leonard Aster
PREVIOUSLY WITH ASC: More than 137 roles in 113 productions, including the title roles in Coriolanus; King Lear; Edward II; Timon of Athens; The Merchant of Venice; Pericles; Doctor Faustus; …

Christopher Seiler *
Mrs. Bumbrake
Christopher Seiler is a seasoned actor and musician whose performances embody transformation and connection, captivating audiences at ASC and beyond.

Shunté Lofton
Captain Robert Falcon Scott
THIS SEASON: Anne Page, John Rugby in The Merry Wives of Windsor; Sir Walter Blunt, Lady Mortimer, Francis in Henry IV, Part 1; Aaliyah Essam in…

Chris Johnston
Grempkin
Chris Johnston has over 20 years of theatre experience and more than 120 productions at the American Shakespeare Center.

Greg Brostrom *
Black Stache
THIS SEASON: Richard in RICHARD III

Allison Glenzer
Smee
More than 186 roles in 101 productions, including Volumnia in Coriolanus, Olivia in Twelfth Night; Regan in King Lear; Margaret in both Henry VI, Part 1 and Part 2; Isabella in Measure for Measure;…

David Anthony Lewis *
Bill Slank
David Anthony Lewis is an accomplished Actor with over 70 professional theatre credits A Christmas Carol 2024 is his 36th production with ASC.

Tim Sailer
Alf
Polonius, Fortinbras in Hamlet; Northumberland in Richard II; Polonius, Fortinbras in Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead; Mirabell in The Way of the World; Alberto, Page in Antonio’s Revenge.

Chris Johnston
Mack
Chris Johnston has over 20 years of theatre experience and more than 120 productions at the American Shakespeare Center.

Chris Johnston
Sanchez
Chris Johnston has over 20 years of theatre experience and more than 120 productions at the American Shakespeare Center.

Chris Johnston
Fighting Prawn
Chris Johnston has over 20 years of theatre experience and more than 120 productions at the American Shakespeare Center.

David Anthony Lewis *
Hawking Clam
David Anthony Lewis is an accomplished Actor with over 70 professional theatre credits A Christmas Carol 2024 is his 36th production with ASC.

Christopher Seiler *
Teacher
Christopher Seiler is a seasoned actor and musician whose performances embody transformation and connection, captivating audiences at ASC and beyond.
Artistic Team
Jim Warren
Director
Jim Warren is the Artistic Director and Co-Founder of the American Shakespeare Center. He directed ASC’s first show, Richard III (in which he played Buckingham), and by the end of …

Chris Johnston
Music Director
Chris Johnston has over 20 years of theatre experience and more than 120 productions at the American Shakespeare Center.

Stephanie Holladay Earl
Choreography & Movement
Stephanie Holladay Earl is an accomplished actor, director, choreographer, & educator with over 15 years of experience, known for her impactful work.
Catie Osborn
Asst. Stage Manager/Understudy
Favorite credits include Cressida/Hector (Troilus and Cressida) and Puck (Midsummer Night’s Dream) with Compass Shakespeare Ensemble. She has previously worked with Great River Shakespeare Festival as an Education Artist (and graphic designer). She holds an MFA and MLitt in Shakespeare and Performance from Mary Baldwin University.
Tweet Me: @CatieOsaurus

Jenny McNee
Costume Designer
Jenny McNee joined the ASC in 2002 after studying in Richmond, Charlottesville, and Edinburgh, Scotland. She has designed and built nearly 100 shows (60 resident and touring shows, 35 holiday …
Liz Schneider
Assistant Costume Designer
Beginning in 2012 as a Costume Shop Intern, Liz Schneider now performs dual duty as Assistant Costume Designer and Costume Liaison for the Actors’ Renaissance Season. Over the past four …
Christopher Moneymaker
Properties Master
Chris has been designing and building props for the ASC since 2012. In that time, he’s provided props for over 60 productions, including (from Shakespeare): The Merchant of Venice; The Two Gentlemen of Verona; Cymbeline; King John; Love’s Labour’s Lost; Twelfth Night; Julius Caesar; Henry VIII; The Two Noble Kinsmen; Romeo and Juliet; All’s Well That Ends Well; Troilus and Cressida; Othello; The Merry Wives of Windsor; Henry IV, Part 1; As You Like It; Timon of Athens; Macbeth; The Comedy of Errors; Pericles; Hamlet; Much Ado about Nothing; The Taming of the Shrew; Antony and Cleopatra; A Midsummer Night’s Dream; The Winter’s Tale; Henry VI, Parts 1, 2, and 3; Henry V; The Tempest; Measure for Measure; and King Lear.

Patrick Earl
Fight Director
Mercutio and Montague in Romeo and Juliet and Dromio of Ephesus in The Comedy of Errors; Fight Captain

David F. Meldman
Understudy/Production Intern
David holds a B.A. in Theatre Studies from the University of Wisconsin, an M.F.A. in Acting from Florida Atlantic University, and is currently pursuing an M.Litt degree in Mary Baldwin’s …
STUFF THAT HAPPENS in THE PLAY
- A troupe of actors addresses the audience.
- At the docks in Victorian England, a schoolmaster ushers three orphan boys (Ted, Prentiss, and a nameless Boy) aboard the disheveled Neverland, a ship bound for the court of the evil King Zarboff.
- The distinguished Lord Aster, who is boarding the neighboring (and much more impressive) ship, the Wasp, sees his daughter Molly and her nanny Mrs. Bumbrake aboard the Neverland.
- Slank, the vicious captain of the Neverland, switches a trunk destined for the Wasp to the decks of the Neverland.
- Molly and the mysterious Boy lock eyes on deck.
- Aboard the Neverland, Molly and the orphan boys realize the ship is much more dangerous than it appeared. Molly sneaks out of her cabin after Alf, a kind-hearted and romantic sailor, and discovers the orphan boys stashed below deck.
- Meanwhile, a band of pirates, led by the wildly wicked Black Stache, has taken control of the Wasp.
- Molly realizes her father is in trouble; then she and the orphans see a flying cat. The orphans try to get Molly to explain what’s going on, but she distracts them by telling a story.
- On the Wasp, Stache realizes the treasure he’s been seeking on this ship has been moved to the Neverland.
- The Boy spies Molly on deck communicating with her father and pries her secret out of her: she and her father are Starcatchers, and they’re protecting a magical treasure – Starstuff.
- Slank discovers the Boy on deck and throws him overboard. Molly swims him to safety.
- Stache attacks the Neverland in search of the treasure. Lightning hits the ship, splits it in half, and it begins to sink.
- The Boy tries to protect the trunk from Stache, but Stache tries to woo him to the pirate’s life, starting with offering him a good pirate name – Peter. The Boy takes Peter as his name.
- The ship goes down, and everyone escapes to a nearby island.
- Mermaids, Mollusks, flying crocodiles, and growing up ensue.
Oh, THERE YOU ARE, PETER!
When my teenage daughter was four years old, she went through a major Peter Pan phase. I picked up J.M. Barrie’s original 1904 play and every Peter book, movie, and game I could get my hands on. We read books out loud, we acted them out; we dove into the waters and flew through the air on our couches and chairs and beds, in search of adventures in Neverland. The magical stories about the boy who wouldn’t grow up set our imaginations ablaze and gave us great big gobs of fun. One of the novels I found was Peter and the Starcatchers by Dave Berry and Ridly Pearson. As my kid and I began reading it, I realized pretty quickly that this amazing book was a bit too “old” for me and my four-year-old. I ended up reading it on my own and falling in love with the brave and mysterious Molly as she befriends a nameless orphan Boy and they both discover how Starstuff will make you what you want to be.
This play, based on that novel, shows us how a nameless kid becomes the Boy Who Wouldn’t Grow Up. The way Starcatcher vibes off of J.M. Barrie’s original Peter Pan play and novel is quite similar to the principles behind our new project: Shakespeare’s New Contemporaries. Find out more about this industry-changing international playwriting competition that seeks a new partner play for each of Shakespeare’s 38 classics on p.25 of this program or at www.sncproject.com.
But the structure and style of this play (and our production) do more than provide a vehicle for a Peter Pan prequel; it’s also about imagination and community – the Starstuff that permeates what the ASC has been doing for twenty-nine years. Starcatcher playwright, Rick Elice, writes the following in the Production Handbook that goes out to the companies who produce this play:
We wanted to make sure the play would reflect what all of us love most about the theatre – a sense of being a part of something bigger than yourself. Community. We begin with a mob of actors…a community waiting to happen, and we end it with those same people, back with a purpose – to lift Peter up in flight. And we know it’s the beginning of something.
It’s that collective strength and community purpose – your community here – that I hope you’ll remember. It’s what this play is about, but it’s also what theatre is for – why we love and need it so. Since 2007, Peter and the Starcatcher has traveled across the country, to Broadway and beyond. And its magic has traveled intact – the result of years of collaboration, ingenuity, family, and love. However you do it, make sure you do it for one another, for family, for community. Trust me, that’s the secret to staying (or at lease feeling) young forever.
This “story theatre” play is perfectly suited for the ASC, our use of Shakespeare’s Staging Conditions, and Shakespeare’s Theatre of Imagination. It’s tailor-made for families and the kid inside us all who craves adventure and a place to belong.
JIM WARREN
ASC Artistic Director and Co-Founder








